The over tip leakage (OTL) flow that exists between the stationary casing and the rotor tip of a shroudless HP turbine remains a major source of loss of performance for modern aero gas turbines. To date the principal approaches to reducing OTL loss have been to minimize the clearance gap and/or apply a rotating shroud to the rotor. Tip clearance control systems continue to improve, but a practical limit on tip gap remains. A rotating shroud is highly effective but increases the rotor weight, forcing it to run more slowly and thus increasing other aerodynamic losses. Additional means of reducing OTL loss are still needed. Partial shrouds (winglets) have been tried but none have entered commercial service to date. This paper presents a novel design of partial shroud derived from a review of past research. The (arbitrary) objectives were to halve the OTL loss of a shroudless rotor, at less than half the size of a full shroud. This design has been analyzed using a steady flow RANS CFD code to qualitatively determine its benefits. Attention has been paid to its validation and a realistic determination of its capabilities. The winglet is predicted to significantly improve the efficiency of a highly loaded HP turbine, by 1.2 percent–1.8 percent at 2 percent tip gap/span. A detailed understanding of the flow field shows this to be credible.

Issue Section:
Technical Papers
Keywords:
gas turbines, rotors, flow simulation, flow control, aerodynamics, losses, vortices
Topics:
Flow (Dynamics), Pressure, Rotors, Turbines
1.
Denton, J. D., 1993, “Loss Mechanisms in Turbomachines,” ASME 93-GT-435.
2.
VKI Lecture Series, 1997, “Secondary and Tip-Clearance Flows in Axial Turbines,” VKI LS 1997-01.
3.
Sieverding, C. H., 1985, “Secondary Flows in Straight and Annular Turbine Cascades,” Thermodynamics and Fluids of Turbomachinery, A. S. Ucer, P. Stowe, and Ch. Hirsch, eds., Nato Series, Vol. II, pp. 621–624.
4.
Bindon, J. P., 1988, “The Measurement and Formation of Tip Clearance Loss,” ASME 88-GT-203.
5.
Moore
,
J.
, and
Tilton
,
J. S.
,
1988
, “
Tip Leakage Flow in a Linear Turbine Cascade
,”
ASME J. Turbomach.
,
100
, pp.
18
–
26
.
6.
Heyes, F. J., and Hodson, H. P., 1992, “The Measurement and Prediction of Tip Clearance Flow in Linear Turbine Cascades,” ASME 92-GT-214.
7.
Yaras, M. L., and Sjolander, S. A., 1991, “Effects of Simulated Rotation on Tip Leakage in a Planar Cascade of Turbine Blades. Part I: Tip Gan Flow,” ASME 91-GT-127.
8.
Yaras, M. I., and Sjolander, S. A., 1991, “Effects of Simulated Rotation on Tip Leakage in a Planar Cascade of Turbine Blades. Part II: Downstream Flow Field and Blade Loading,” ASME 91-GT-128.
9.
Morphis, G., and Bindon, J. P., 1988, “The Effects of Relative Motion, Blade Edge Radius and Gap Size on Blade Tip Pressure Distribution in an Annular Cascade with Clearance,” ASME 88-GT-256
10.
Heyes, F. J. G., Hodson, H. P., and Dailey, G. M., 1991, “The Effect of Blade Tip Geometry on the Tip Leakage Flow in Axial Turbine Cascades,” ASME 91-GT-135.
11.
Yamamoto
,
A.
,
1989
, “
Endwall Flow/Loss Mechanisms in a Linear Turbine Cascade with Tip Clearance
,”
ASME J. Turbomach.
,
111
, pp.
264
–
275
.
12.
Govardan, M., Venktrayulu, N., Vishnubhotla, and V. S., 1993, “Tip Clearance Effects on the Flow Field of an Axial Turbine Rotor Blade Cascade,” ISABE 93-7057.
13.
Graham, J. A. H., 1985, “Investigation of a Tip Clearance Cascade in a Water Analogy Rig,” ASME 85-IGT-65.
14.
Chan, J. K. K., Yaras, M. I., and Sjolander, S. A., 1994, “Interaction Between Inlet Boundary Layer, Tip-Leakage and Secondary Flows in a Low-Speed Turbine Cascade,” ASME 94-GT-250.
15.
Bindon, J. P., and Morphis, G., 1990, “The Development of Axial Turbine Leakage Loss for Two Profiled Tip Geometries Using Linear Cascade Data,” ASME 90-GT-152.
16.
Morphis, G., and Bindon, J. P., 1994, “The Flow in a Second Stage Nozzle of a Low Speed Axial Turbine and its Effect on Tip Clearance Loss Development,” ASME 94-GT-145.
17.
Morphis, G., and Bindon, J. P., 1994, “The Performance of a Low Speed One and a Half Stage Axial Turbine with Varying Rotor Tip Clearance and Tip Gap Geometry,” ASME 94-GT-481.
18.
Yamamoto, A., Tominga, J., and Matsunuma, T., 1994, “Detailed Measurements of Three-Dimensional Flows and Losses Inside an Axial Flow Turbine Rotor,” ASME 94-GT-348.
19.
Yamamoto, A., Matsunuma, T., and Ikeuchi, K., 1994, “Unsteady Endwall/Tip-Clearance Flows and Losses Due to Turbine Rotor-Stator Interaction,” ASME 94-GT-461.
20.
Stakolich
,
E. G.
, and
Stromberg
,
W. J.
,
1983
, “
JT9D Performance Deterioration Results From a Simulated Aerodynamic Load Test
,”
AIAA J. Aircraft
,
20
, No.
8
, pp.
650
–
658
.
21.
Hourmouziadis, J., and Albrecht, G., 1987, “An Integrated Aero/Mechanical Performance Approach to High Technology Turbine Design,” AGARD-CP-421, “Advanced Technology for Aero Gas Turbine Components.”
22.
Hartley, R., 1996, “High Pressure Turbine Tip Clearance Performance Investigation,” M.Sc. thesis, Cranfield University.
23.
Dishart, P. T., and Moore, J., 1989, “Tip Leakage Losses in a Linear Turbine Cascade,” ASME 89-GT-56.
24.
Yaras, M. I., and Sjolander, S. A., 1990, “Prediction of Tip-Leakage Losses in Axial Turbines,” ASME 90-GT-154.
25.
Peters, D. W., and Moore, J., 1996, “Tip Leakage Loss Development in a Linear Turbine Cascade,” AGARD CP 571-12.
26.
Booth T. C., Dodge, P. R., and Hepworth, H. K., 1981, “Rotor-Tip Leakage Part I—Basic Methodology,” ASME 81-GT-71.
27.
Moore, J., and Elward, K. M., 1992, “Shock Formation in Overexpanded Tip Leakage Flow,” ASME 92-GT-1.
28.
Moore
,
J.
,
Moore
,
J. G.
, and
Henry
,
G. S.
,
1989
, “
Flow and Heat Transfer in Turbine Tip Gaps
,”
ASME J. Turbomach.
,
111
, pp.
73
–
79
.
29.
Metzger, D., Rued, K., and Chyu, M., (1989), “Influence of Clearance leakage on Turbine Heat Transfer at and near Blade Tips. Summary of Recent Results,” AIAA 89-0327.
30.
Bindon, J. P., 1987, “Pressure Distributions in the Tip Clearance Region of an Unshrouded Axial Turbine as Affecting the Problem of Tip Burnout,” ASME 87-GT-230.
31.
Patel, K. V., 1980, “Research on a High Work Axial Gas Generator Turbine,” SAE 800618.
32.
Staubach, J. B., Sharma, O. P., and Stetson, G. M., 1996, “Reduction of Tip Clearance Losses Through 3-D Airfoil Designs,” ASME 96-TA-13.
33.
Farokhi
,
S.
,
1988
, “
Analysis of Rotor Tip Clearance Loss in Axial-Flow Turbines
,”
J. Propulsion
,
4
, No.
5
, pp.
452
–
457
.
34.
De Cecco, S., Yaras, M. L., and Sjolander, S. A., 1995, “Measurements of the Tip-Leakage Flow in a Turbine Cascade With Large Clearances,” ASME 95-GT-77.
35.
Offenburg, L. S., Fischer, J. D., and Hoek, T. J., 1987, “An Experimental Investigation of Turbine Case Treatments,” AIAA-87-1919.
36.
Harvey, N. W., 1997, “Over Tip Leakage Control in Axial Flow Turbines,” M.Sc. thesis, Cranfield University.
37.
Moore J. G., 1985, “Calculation of 3D Flow Without Numerical Mixing,” AGARD-LS-140 on 3D Computation Techniques Applied to Internal Flows in Propulsion Systems, pp. 8.1–8.15.
38.
Moore H., and Gregory-Smith D. G., 1996, “Transition Effects on Secondary Flows in a Turbine Cascade,” ASME 96-GT-100.
39.
Robinson C. J., Northall J. D., and McFarlane C., 1989, “Measurement and Calculation of the Three-Dimensional Flow in Axial Compressor Stators, With and Without End Bends,” ASME 89-GT-6.
40.
Lapworth
,
B. L.
,
1993
, “
Three-Dimensional Mesh Embedding for the Navier-Stokes Equations Using Upwind Control Volumes
,”
Int. J. Numer. Methods Fluids
,
17
, pp.
195
–
220
.
41.
Bindon
,
J. P.
,
1980
, “
Exit Plane and Suction Surface Flows in an Annular Turbine Cascade With a Skewed Inlet Boundary Layer
,”
Int. J. Heat Fluid Flow
,
2
, No.
2
, pp.
57
–
66
.
42.
Harvey, N. W., Rose, M. G., Coupland, J., and Jones, T. V., 1998, “Measurement and Calculation of Nozzle Guide Vane End Wall Heat Transfer,” ASME 98-GT-66.
43.
White F. M., 1991, Viscous Fluid Flow, McGraw-Hill, New York.
44.
Spalding D. B., and Patankar S. V., 1967, “Heat and Mass Transfer in Boundary Layers,” Morgan-Grampian.
45.
Moore, J., and Moore, J. G., 1991, “A Computational Study of Tip Leakage Flow and Losses in a Linear Turbine Cascade,” AGARD Conference Proceedings No. 510 on CFD Techniques for Propulsion Applications, San Antonio, Texas.
46.
Sheard, A. G., 1989, “Aerodynamic and Mechanical Performance of a High Pressure Turbine Stage in a Transient Wind Tunnel,” D.Phil. thesis, University of Oxford.
47.
Dietz, A. J., 1990, “Blade Surface Pressure Measurements on the Rotor of a Model Turbine Stage in a Transient Flow Facility,” D. Phil. thesis, University of Oxford.
48.
Garside, T., 1995, “The Heat Transfer and Aerodynamic Performance of a Rotating Turbine in the Absence of Upstream Nozzle Guide Vanes,” D. Phil. thesis, Oxford University.
49.
Yamamoto, A., and Nouse, H., 1988, “Effects of Incidence on Three-Dimensional Flows in a Linear Turbine Cascade,” ASME 88-GT-110.
50.
Doorney, D. J., Davis, R. L., Edwards, D. E., and Madavan, N. K., 1990, “Unsteady Analysis of Hot Streak Migration in a Turbine Stage,” AIAA-90-2354.
51.
Lee, Ching-Pang, Pietraszkiewicz, E. F., Prakash, C., and Zerkle, R. D., 1994, “Turbine Blade Having Tip Slot,” U.S. patent 5503527.
52.
Harvey, N. W., 1996, “Turbine Rotor Blades,” Patent GB 9607578.
Copyright © 2001
 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.