Abstract
The ongoing COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the acceptance of virtual team collaboration as a replacement for face-to-face collaboration. Unlike face-to-face collaboration, virtual collaboration is influenced by unique factors, such as technology mediation. However, there is a lack of rigorous research that assesses the impact of virtual collaboration on the engineering design process. Therefore, the current study investigates the effect of virtual team collaboration on design outcomes by means of the model of influence, learning, and norms in organizations (MILANO) framework. To tailor MILANO for virtual collaboration, this paper first presents an empirical study of human design teams, which shows how model parameter values for face-to-face collaboration (like self-efficacy, perceived influencers, perceived degree of influence, trust and familiarity) differ from appropriate parameter values for face-to-face collaboration. The simulation results for both virtual and face-to-face collaboration show how design outcomes differ with collaboration mode. Unlike teams with a few well-defined influential individuals, the mode of collaboration does not have a significant impact on teams where all individuals are equally influential. Virtual collaboration also results in lower exploration and variety than face-to-face collaboration.
Issue Section:
Design Automation
References
1.
Waizenegger
, L.
, McKenna
, B.
, Cai
, W.
, and Bendz
, T.
, 2020
, “An Affordance Perspective of Team Collaboration and Enforced Working From Home During COVID-19
,” Eur. J. Inf. Syst.
, 29
(4
), pp. 429
–442
. 2.
Boland
, B.
, De Smet
, A.
, Palter
, R.
, and Sanghvi
, A.
, 2020
, Reimagining the Office and Work Life After COVID-19
, McKinsey & Company
.3.
Kiesler
, S.
, and Cummings
, J.
, 2002
, “What Do We Know About Proximity and Distance in Work Groups? A Legacy of Research,” Distributed Work
, 1st ed., P.
Hinds
, and S.
Kiesler
, eds., MIT Press
, Cambridge
, pp. 57
–80
.4.
Martins
, L. L.
, Gilson
, L. L.
, and Maynard
, M. T.
, 2004
, “Virtual Teams: What Do We Know and Where Do We Go From Here?
,” J. Manage.
, 30
(6
), pp. 805
–835
. 5.
Griffith
, T. L.
, and Neale
, M. A.
, 2001
, “8 Information Processing in Traditional, Hybrid, and Virtual Teams: From Nascent Knowledge to Transactive Memory
,” Res. Organ. Behav.
, 23
, pp. 379
–421
. 6.
Powell
, A.
, Piccoli
, G.
, and Ives
, B.
, 2004
, “Virtual Teams: A Review of Current Literature and Directions for Future Research
,” ACM SIGMIS Database
, 35
(1
), pp. 6
–36
. 7.
Alsharo
, M.
, Gregg
, D.
, and Ramirez
, R.
, 2017
, “Virtual Team Effectiveness: The Role of Knowledge Sharing and Trust
,” Inf. Manage.
, 54
(4
), pp. 479
–490
. 8.
Jarvenpaa
, S. L.
, and Leidner
, D. E.
, 1999
, “Communication and Trust in Global Virtual Teams
,” Organ. Sci.
, 10
(6
), pp. 791
–815
. 9.
Hemetsberger
, A.
, and Reinhardt
, C.
, 2009
, “Collective Development in Open-Source Communities: An Activity Theoretical Perspective on Successful Online Collaboration
,” Organ. Stud.
, 30
(9
), pp. 987
–1008
. 10.
Piccoli
, G.
, Powell
, A.
, and Ives
, B.
, 2004
, “Virtual Teams: Team Control Structure, Work Processes, and Team Effectiveness
,” Inf. Technol. People
, 17
(4
), pp. 359
–379
. 11.
Montoya
, M. M.
, Massey
, A. P.
, and Lockwood
, N. S.
, 2011
, “3D Collaborative Virtual Environments: Exploring the Link Between Collaborative Behaviors and Team Performance
,” Decis. Sci.
, 42
(2
), pp. 451
–476
. 12.
Warkentin
, M. E.
, Sayeed
, L.
, and Hightower
, R.
, 1997
, “Virtual Teams Versus Face-to-Face Teams: An Exploratory Study of a Web-Based Conference System
,” Decis. Sci.
, 28
(4
), pp. 975
–996
. 13.
Malhotra
, A.
, and Majchrzak
, A.
, 2014
, “Enhancing Performance of Geographically Distributed Teams Through Targeted Use of Information and Communication Technologies
,” Hum. Relat.
, 67
(4
), pp. 389
–411
. 14.
Winter
, A.
, 2020
, “Problems Working in Semi and Full-Time Virtual Teams: Comparison of Virtual Team Problems Pre and Post-COVID 19 Epidemic
,” Bachelor’s thesis
, University of Twente
, Enschede
.15.
Hinds
, P. J.
, and Bailey
, D. E.
, 2003
, “Out of Sight, Out of Sync: Understanding Conflict in Distributed Teams
,” Organ. Sci.
, 14
(6
), pp. 615
–632
. 16.
Mortensen
, M.
, and Hinds
, P. J.
, 2001
, “Conflict and Shared Identity in Geographically Distributed Teams
,” Int. J. Confl. Manage.
, 12
(3
), pp. 212
–238
. 17.
Levitt
, B.
, and March
, J. G.
, 1988
, “Organizational Learning
,” Annu. Rev. Sociol.
, 14
(1
), pp. 319
–338
. 18.
Moussaïd
, M.
, Kämmer
, J. E.
, Analytis
, P. P.
, and Neth
, H.
, 2013
, “Social Influence and the Collective Dynamics of Opinion Formation
,” PLoS One
, 8
(11
), p. e78433
. 19.
Thomas
, K. W.
, 1992
, “Conflict and Negotiation Processes in Organizations,” Handbook of Industrial and Organizational Psychology
, Vol. 3
, M. D.
Dunnette
, and L. M.
Hough
, eds., Consulting Psychologists Press
, pp. 651
–717
.20.
Axtell
, C. M.
, Fleck
, S. J.
, and Turner
, N.
, 2004
, “Virtual Teams: Collaborating Across Distance
,” Int. Rev. Ind. Organ. Psychol.
, 19
, pp. 205
–248
. 21.
Peters
, L. M.
, and Manz
, C. C.
, 2007
, “Identifying Antecedents of Virtual Team Collaboration
,” Team Perform. Manage.
, 13
(3–4
), pp. 1352
–7592
. 22.
Isohätälä
, J.
, Järvenoja
, H.
, and Järvelä
, S.
, 2017
, “Socially Shared Regulation of Learning and Participation in Social Interaction in Collaborative Learning
,” Int. J. Educ. Res.
, 81
, pp. 11
–24
. 23.
González
, M. G.
, Burke
, M. J.
, Santuzzi
, A. M.
, and Bradley
, J. C.
, 2003
, “The Impact of Group Process Variables on the Effectiveness of Distance Collaboration Groups
,” Comput. Hum. Behav.
, 19
(5
), pp. 629
–648
. 24.
Choi
, O. K.
, and Cho
, E.
, 2019
, “The Mechanism of Trust Affecting Collaboration in Virtual Teams and the Moderating Roles of the Culture of Autonomy and Task Complexity
,” Comput. Hum. Behav.
, 91
, pp. 305
–315
. 25.
Baturay
, M. H.
, and Toker
, S.
, 2019
, “The Comparison of Trust in Virtual and Face-to-Face Collaborative Learning Teams
,” Turk. Online J. Distance Educ.
, 20
(3
), pp. 153
–164
. 26.
DeRosa
, D. M.
, Hantula
, D. A.
, Kock
, N.
, and D’Arcy
, J.
, 2004
, “Trust and Leadership in Virtual Teamwork: A Media Naturalness Perspective
,” Hum. Resour. Manage.
, 43
(2–3
), pp. 219
–232
. 27.
Lea
, M.
, and Spears
, R.
, 1991
, “Computer-Mediated Communication, De-Individuation and Group Decision-Making
,” Int. J. Man-Mach. Stud.
, 34
(2
), pp. 283
–301
. 28.
Vamos
, A.
, Fülöp
, I.
, Resko
, B.
, and Baranyi
, P.
, 2010
, “Collaboration in Virtual Reality of Intelligent Agents
,” Acta Electrotech. Inform.
, 10
(2
), pp. 21
–27
.29.
Wallis
, A.
, Haag
, Z.
, and Foley
, R.
, 1998
, “A Multi-Agent Framework for Distributed Collaborative Design
,” Proceedings of the Seventh IEEE International Workshop on Enabling Technologies: Infrastructure for Collaborative Enterprises (WET ICE’98)
, Stanford, CA
, June 17–19
, IEEE, pp. 282
–287
.30.
Lapp
, S.
, Jablokow
, K.
, and McComb
, C.
, 2019
, “KABOOM: An Agent-Based Model for Simulating Cognitive Styles in Team Problem Solving
,” Des. Sci.
, 5
(13
), pp. 1
–32
. 31.
Olson
, J.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2009
, “Unlocking Organizational Potential: A Computational Platform for Investigating Structural Interdependence in Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 131
(3
), p. 031001
. 32.
Hanna Landry
, L.
, and Cagan
, J.
, 2011
, “Search Strategies in Evolutionary Multi-Agent Systems: The Effect of Cooperation and Reward on Solution Quality
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 133
(6
), p. 061005
. 33.
McComb
, C.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2016
, “Drawing Inspiration From Human Design Teams for Better Search and Optimization: The Heterogeneous Simulated Annealing Teams Algorithm
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 138
(4
), p. 044501
. 34.
Landry
, L. H.
, and Cagan
, J.
, 2011
, “Protocol-Based Multi-Agent Systems: Examining the Effect of Diversity, Dynamism, and Cooperation in Heuristic Optimization Approaches
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 133
(2
), p. 021001
. 35.
Dionne
, S. D.
, Sayama
, H.
, Hao
, C.
, and Bush
, B. J.
, 2010
, “The Role of Leadership in Shared Mental Model Convergence and Team Performance Improvement: An Agent-Based Computational Model
,” Leadersh. Q.
, 21
(6
), pp. 1035
–1049
. 36.
Singh
, V.
, Dong
, A.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 2011
, “How Important Is Team Structure to Team Performance?
” DS 68-7: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED 11)
, Copenhagen, Denmark
, Aug. 15–18
, pp. 117
–126
.37.
McComb
, C.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2017
, “Optimizing Design Teams Based on Problem Properties: Computational Team Simulations and an Applied Empirical Test
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 139
(4
), p. 041101
. 38.
Fernandes
, J. V.
, Henriques
, E.
, Silva
, A.
, and Pimentel
, C.
, 2017
, “Modelling the Dynamics of Complex Early Design Processes: An Agent-Based Approach
,” Des. Sci.
, 3
(19
), pp. 1
–34
. 39.
Cao
, S.
, MacLaren
, N. G.
, Cao
, Y.
, Dong
, Y.
, Sayama
, H.
, Yammarino
, F. J.
, Dionne
, S. D.
, Mumford
, M. D.
, Connelly
, S.
, Martin
, R.
, Standish
, C. J.
, Newbold
, T. R.
, England
, S.
, and Ruark
, G. A.
, 2020
, “An Agent-Based Model of Leader Emergence and Leadership Perception Within a Collective
,” Complexity
, 2020
, pp. 1
–11
. 40.
Wu
, Z.
, and Duffy
, A. H.
, 2004
, “Modeling Collective Learning in Design
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 18
(4
), pp. 289
–313
. 41.
Saunders
, R.
, and Gero
, J. S.
, 2004
, “Curious Agents and Situated Design Evaluations
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 18
(2
), pp. 153
–161
. 42.
Singh
, V.
, 2009
, Computational Studies on the Role of Social Learning in the Formation of Team Mental Models
, Design Lab Faculty of Architecture, Design and Planning, The University of Sydney
, Sydney
.43.
Singh
, H.
, Cascini
, G.
, and McComb
, C.
, 2021
, “Influencers in Design Teams: A Computational Framework to Study Their Impact on Idea Generation
,” Artif. Intell. Eng. Des. Anal. Manuf.
, 35
(3
), pp. 332
–352
. 44.
Singh
, H.
, Cascini
, G.
, and McComb
, C.
, in press
, “Idea Selection in Design Teams: A Computational Framework and Insights in the Presence of Influencers
,” Des. Sci.
45.
Simon
, H. A.
, 1981
, The Sciences of the Artificial
, 2nd ed., MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
.46.
Ball
, L. J.
, Maskill
, L.
, and Ormerod
, T. C.
, 1998
, “Satisficing in Engineering Design: Causes, Consequences and Implications for Design Support
,” Autom. Constr.
, 7
(2–3
), pp. 213
–227
. 47.
Sayama
, H.
, Farrell
, D. L.
, and Dionne
, S. D.
, 2010
, “The Effects of Mental Model Formation on Group Decision Making: An Agent-Based Simulation
,” Complexity
, 16
(3
), pp. 49
–57
. 48.
Haerem
, T.
, and Rau
, D.
, 2007
, “The Influence of Degree of Expertise and Objective Task Complexity on Perceived Task Complexity and Performance
,” J. Appl. Psychol.
, 92
(5
), pp. 1320
–1331
. 49.
Ahmed
, S.
, Wallace
, K. M.
, and Blessing
, L. T.
, 2003
, “Understanding the Differences Between How Novice and Experienced Designers Approach Design Tasks
,” Res. Eng. Des.
, 14
(1
), pp. 1
–11
. 50.
Singh
, H.
, Cascini
, G.
, and McComb
, C.
, 2021
, “Comparing Design Outcomes Achieved by Teams of Expert and Novice Designers Through Agent-Based Simulation
,” Proceedings of the Design Society: International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED 2021)
, Online
, August
, pp. 661
–670
.51.
Carberry
, A. R.
, Lee
, H. S.
, and Ohland
, M. W.
, 2010
, “Measuring Engineering Design Self-Efficacy
,” J. Eng. Educ.
, 99
(1
), pp. 71
–79
. 52.
Ohland
, M. W.
, Loughry
, M. L.
, Woehr
, D. J.
, Bullard
, L. G.
, Felder
, R. M.
, Finelli
, C. J.
, Layton
, R. A.
, Pomeranz
, H. R.
, and Schmucker
, D. G.
, 2012
, “The Comprehensive Assessment of Team Member Effectiveness: Development of a Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale for Self-and Peer Evaluation
,” Acad. Manage. Learn. Educ.
, 11
(4
), pp. 609
–630
. 53.
Francescato
, D.
, Porcelli
, R.
, Mebane
, M.
, Cuddetta
, M.
, Klobas
, J.
, and Renzi
, P.
, 2006
, “Evaluation of the Efficacy of Collaborative Learning in Face-to-Face and Computer-Supported University Contexts
,” Comput. Hum. Behav.
, 22
(2
), pp. 163
–176
. 54.
Stark
, E. M.
, and Bierly
, P. E.
, III, 2009
, “An Analysis of Predictors of Team Satisfaction in Product Development Teams With Differing Levels of Virtualness
,” Res. Dev. Manage.
, 39
(5
), pp. 461
–472
. 55.
Berry
, G. R.
, 2011
, “A Cross-Disciplinary Literature Review: Examining Trust on Virtual Teams
,” Perform. Improv. Q.
, 24
(3
), pp. 9
–28
. 56.
Wilson
, J. M.
, Straus
, S. G.
, and McEvily
, B.
, 2006
, “All in Due Time: The Development of Trust in Computer-Mediated and Face-to-Face Teams
,” Organ. Behav. Hum. Decis. Process.
, 99
(1
), pp. 16
–33
. 57.
Maier
, A. M.
, Kreimeyer
, M.
, Lindemann
, U.
, and Clarkson
, P. J.
, 2009
, “Reflecting Communication: A Key Factor for Successful Collaboration Between Embodiment Design and Simulation
,” J. Eng. Des.
, 20
(3
), pp. 265
–287
. 58.
Hinds
, P. J.
, and Mortensen
, M.
, 2005
, “Understanding Conflict in Geographically Distributed Teams: The Moderating Effects of Shared Identity, Shared Context, and Spontaneous Communication
,” Organ. Sci.
, 16
(3
), pp. 290
–307
. 59.
Syna Desivilya
, H.
, and Eizen
, D.
, 2005
, “Conflict Management in Work Teams: The Role of Social Self-Efficacy and Group Identification
,” Int. J. Confl. Manage.
, 16
(2
), pp. 183
–208
. 60.
Allen
, T. J.
, 1977
, “Managing the Flow of Technology
,” PhD thesis
, MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
.61.
Schulze
, J.
, Schultze
, M.
, West
, S. G.
, and Krumm
, S.
, 2017
, “The Knowledge, Skills, Abilities, and Other Characteristics Required for Face-to-Face Versus Computer-Mediated Communication: Similar or Distinct Constructs?
,” J. Bus. Psychol.
, 32
(3
), pp. 283
–300
. 62.
Schulze
, J.
, and Krumm
, S.
, 2017
, “The “Virtual Team Player:” A Review and Initial Model of Knowledge, Skills, Abilities, and Other Characteristics for Virtual Collaboration
,” Organ. Psychol. Rev.
, 7
(1
), pp. 66
–95
. 63.
Chamakiotis
, P.
, Dekoninck
, E. A.
, and Panteli
, N.
, 2013
, “Factors Influencing Creativity in Virtual Design Teams: An Interplay Between Technology, Teams and Individuals
,” Creativity Innov. Manage.
, 22
(3
), pp. 265
–279
. 64.
Maznevski
, M. L.
, and Chudoba
, K. M.
, 2000
, “Bridging Space Over Time: Global Virtual Team Dynamics and Effectiveness
,” Organ. Sci.
, 11
(5
), pp. 473
–492
. 65.
Shah
, J. J.
, Smith
, S. M.
, and Vargas-Hernandez
, N.
, 2003
, “Metrics for Measuring Ideation Effectiveness
,” Des. Stud.
, 24
(2
), pp. 111
–134
. 66.
Dorst
, K.
, and Cross
, N.
, 2001
, “Creativity in the Design Process: Co-Evolution of Problem-Solution
,” Des. Stud.
, 22
(5
), pp. 425
–437
. 67.
Brownell
, E.
, Cagan
, J.
, and Kotovsky
, K.
, 2021
, “Only as Strong as the Strongest Link: The Relative Contribution of Individual Team Member Proficiency in Configuration Design
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 143
(8
), p. 081402
. 68.
Walthall
, C. J.
, Devanathan
, S.
, Kisselburgh
, L. G.
, Ramani
, K.
, Hirleman
, E. D.
, and Yang
, M. C.
, 2011
, “Evaluating Wikis as a Communicative Medium for Collaboration Within Colocated and Distributed Engineering Design Teams
,” ASME J. Mech. Des.
, 133
(7
), p. 071001
. 69.
Singh
, H.
, Becattini
, N.
, Cascini
, G.
, and Škec
, S.
, 2021
, “How Familiarity Impacts Influence in Collaborative Teams?
” Proceedings of the International Conference on Engineering Design (ICED21)
, Gothenburg, Sweden
, Aug. 16–20
, pp. 1735
–1744
.Copyright © 2022 by ASME
You do not currently have access to this content.
